The Daily Tribune: Most Undervalued Posts of Nov 17

What if every voter had an equal say no matter their Steem Power? The Daily Tribune finds out and highlights those posts that would have been rewarded most but weren't. In ancient Rome, the Tribune of the Plebs was the voice of the people, serving as an important balance to the power of the ruling class. With your help, we hope the Daily Tribune will serve a similar purpose for the Steemit community.

In order to allow highlighted posts to benefit from greater visibility before the first payout, we plan to post twice a day, each covering the prior 12 hours of posts that have had at least 3 hours for votes to come in. Each post will rank the top 80 most undervalued posts for that period.

Please note that this isn't necessarily a direct criticism of Steemit's reward algorithms. An automatic reward system needs to be resilient against more potential abuses than a community driven effort such as this one, in which humans remain in the loop to reward deserving posts with more votes or flag undeserving ones.

Rankings

Nov 17 - Part I (View Yesterday's )

Below each post title, we list some important stats, which take the following form:

# Votes | Equal Voter Payout - Actual Pending Payout = Difference in Value + Time Bonus (# Hours Old) = Projected Difference in Value

If you want to see more about how we rank posts, you can read about some of our methodology, data analysis and technical details in our initial post.

If you'd like to see Steemit's rewards be more democratic, please consider following us as well as browsing the rankings and upvoting posts you agree are undervalued. Also, we are very grateful to @thecryptofiend, @steemitqa, @awesomenyl, @jlufer, @seisges, @barrydutton and any others we missed for the recent resteems.

Rank	Author	Post Title and Stats
1	@steemvoter	Coming Changes Nov 16 2016 897 \| $95.89 - $30.26 = $65.63 + 0.2% (14.2) = $65.73
2	@craig-grant	One of my best performing offers was an online bank called x.com (now PayPal) 308 \| $33.94 - $3.24 = $30.69 + 1.4% (9.0) = $31.13
3	@tee-em	End of Year Goal Achieved! I'm a New Member of the 5000 Steem Power Club! 395 \| $34.01 - $5.49 = $28.52 + 1.3% (9.3) = $28.90
4	@papa-pepper	HOW TO MAKE A GIF - A Simple How-To From @papa-pepper 396 \| $30.16 - $6.82 = $23.34 + 1.5% (9.0) = $23.68
5	@timcliff	Proposal for a Bounty Management Forum 339 \| $26.33 - $4.61 = $21.72 + 1.5% (8.8) = $22.05
6	@exploretraveler	The Jade Market Of Hong Kong 247 \| $21.47 - $0.46 = $21.01 + 2.6% (7.1) = $21.56
7	@l0k1	Ned's Speech at the Closing Dinner 230 \| $20.48 - $0.53 = $19.96 + 2.9% (6.7) = $20.53
8	@exploretraveler	Photo of the day ~ Shopping colorful streets of Taiwan 244 \| $20.08 - $0.48 = $19.60 + 0.8% (10.8) = $19.76
9	@l0k1	Getting Set Up for Development 246 \| $20.44 - $2.57 = $17.87 + 6.2% (4.8) = $18.97
10	@steemship	TIL that it is illegal (usually) to merge onto a U.S highway from an exit lane after the dotted line has turned solid 207 \| $24.28 - $7.42 = $16.86 + 6.2% (4.8) = $17.90
11	@boddhisattva	Mercury skies in winter (original color and B&W photo) #2 160 \| $16.02 - $0.26 = $15.77 + 9.0% (3.7) = $17.18
12	@thecryptofiend	Return to the River God - Part 2: Colour Versions - free photos for you to use in your own posts 305 \| $29.17 - $13.93 = $15.24 + 0.3% (13.5) = $15.29
13	@calaber24p	Best Resources To Learn Japanese 310 \| $23.04 - $11.32 = $11.73 + 0.3% (13.6) = $11.76
14	@future24	📹 The new Steem Film is published and you can watch it on YouTube! 📺 (English/German) 311 \| $28.96 - $17.48 = $11.48 + 0.0% (14.8) = $11.49
15	@bullionstackers	[TIL]Crossing the Ditch - Snail in Action part 3 247 \| $14.83 - $4.46 = $10.36 + 6.6% (4.6) = $11.04
16	@krnel	Symbols in Stone-Age European Cave Art - A Precursor to Language? 266 \| $17.79 - $7.04 = $10.75 + 0.6% (11.9) = $10.82
17	@dana-edwards	Libertarian voluntary basic income 131 \| $11.23 - $0.58 = $10.64 + 0.3% (13.5) = $10.67
18	@royalmacro	Rising of poetry [An Original Poem] 97 \| $10.60 - $0.33 = $10.27 + 2.0% (7.8) = $10.48
19	@everlove	GRATITUDE deeper than words--The Steemian Community Took Me to SteemFest 134 \| $12.88 - $3.01 = $9.87 + 0.2% (13.8) = $9.89
20	@better	The Daily Better - 17 November 2016 167 \| $9.52 - $0.82 = $8.70 + 0.7% (11.6) = $8.76
21	@bola	Guess How Many? #59 71 \| $8.58 - $0.16 = $8.43 + 0.5% (12.3) = $8.47
22	@halo	STEEMIT GIRL HALO The Black #58 81 \| $9.85 - $1.54 = $8.31 + 0.7% (11.5) = $8.37
23	@t-r-f	T-R-F Emergency Fund for those having (had) problems during return from SteemFest 95 \| $12.80 - $4.98 = $7.82 + 6.9% (4.5) = $8.36
24	@canadian-coconut	Fetal Demise in the Womb -- Whistleblower at Medical Billing Company sheds light on Vaccines during Pregnancy 177 \| $9.53 - $1.56 = $7.97 + 1.9% (8.1) = $8.12
25	@screenname	The Daily Tribune: Most Undervalued Posts of Nov 16 - Part II 89 \| $8.94 - $1.98 = $6.96 + 0.6% (12.0) = $7.00
26	@poeticsnake	30 day drawing challenge Day 17 114 \| $6.42 - $0.21 = $6.20 + 12.4% (3.1) = $6.97
27	@doitvoluntarily	Blame Game Vs Personal Responsibility 165 \| $9.62 - $2.69 = $6.94 + 0.2% (13.8) = $6.95
28	@edgarsart	Commissioned Portrait Drawing A3 Size By EdgarsArt 70 \| $7.84 - $1.16 = $6.67 + 3.9% (5.9) = $6.93
29	@dmilash	Reuleaux triangle - you can drill a square hole 82 \| $6.88 - $0.01 = $6.87 + 0.1% (14.7) = $6.87
30	@bola	Fill In The Blank #50 57 \| $6.84 - $0.03 = $6.81 + 0.7% (11.7) = $6.86
31	@woman-onthe-wing	Natural Beauty Using Natural Ingredients - #4 Non-Toxic Personal Care for Infants 122 \| $13.54 - $6.82 = $6.72 + 0.3% (13.6) = $6.73
32	@denvermax	Smoking and Hula Hooping with Denvermax 193 \| $18.41 - $12.06 = $6.35 + 2.7% (7.0) = $6.51
33	@merej99	Her Leading Man - romance fiction - chapter 4 77 \| $6.55 - $0.38 = $6.18 + 1.6% (8.7) = $6.28
34	@acidyo	That moment when... 110 \| $9.17 - $3.09 = $6.08 + 3.1% (6.5) = $6.26
35	@pilgrimtraveler	The Divine call 46 \| $6.21 - $0.07 = $6.14 + 0.7% (11.4) = $6.18
36	@jlufer	The weeping willow for love of neighbor 154 \| $11.16 - $5.11 = $6.05 + 0.8% (11.2) = $6.09
37	@michelle.gent	Deadlier Than The Male - Exclusive to Steemit - Continuing the tale of a brand new Werewolf 58 \| $6.06 - $0.10 = $5.95 + 0.4% (13.0) = $5.98
38	@daveks	Sunset Video at the Pond 181 \| $11.08 - $5.18 = $5.90 + 0.9% (10.7) = $5.95
39	@nanzo-scoop	SOCCER SWEEPSTAKES - Round #9 (RESULTS!) 120 \| $6.50 - $0.60 = $5.89 + 0.2% (13.9) = $5.91
40	@crowdfundedwhale	Crowdfunded Whale: Status Update After 24 Days Since the Start of the Project 132 \| $6.82 - $0.93 = $5.89 + 0.1% (14.4) = $5.90
41	@l0k1	Spotted in Amsterdam - The Smoke Boat 174 \| $18.00 - $12.25 = $5.75 + 0.9% (10.4) = $5.81
42	@halo	STEEMIT GIRL HALO Digital Art #63 59 \| $7.07 - $1.44 = $5.63 + 0.0% (15.0) = $5.63
43	@vegascomic	Comic Book Character Creation - The First Appearance of Liqua 64 \| $5.63 - $0.21 = $5.42 + 0.1% (14.7) = $5.42
44	@arcange	SteemFest Memories - The Day After 83 \| $5.44 - $0.19 = $5.24 + 0.3% (13.3) = $5.26
45	@karenmckersie	🍬THE FIRST ♯1 STEEMIT 😊EMOJI 😆 STORY❗SHORT BUT SWEET❗🍬 160 \| $6.01 - $1.04 = $4.97 + 4.8% (5.4) = $5.21
46	@jlufer	Picture of the day Medicine of the Soul the Appreciation 58 \| $5.05 - $0.04 = $5.01 + 1.3% (9.3) = $5.07
47	@lauralemons	Digital art. -Forest Woman- (merging with nature) WIP 106 \| $5.23 - $0.37 = $4.86 + 3.0% (6.6) = $5.01
48	@bola	Sentence Unscrambler #66 86 \| $5.46 - $0.62 = $4.83 + 2.4% (7.3) = $4.95
49	@arcange	SteemFest Memories - The After Days 130 \| $7.11 - $2.32 = $4.80 + 0.5% (12.3) = $4.82
50	@englishtchrivy	Make A Pasta Dish Out of These Ingredients - A Challenge A Fellow Steemian Threw Me That I Gave In To 203 \| $17.93 - $13.15 = $4.77 + 0.4% (13.2) = $4.79
51	@daveks	the Daily Pic #53 (plus 15 extra photos) 191 \| $12.21 - $7.71 = $4.49 + 2.0% (7.9) = $4.58
52	@acidyo	What people think of my unemployment 144 \| $10.70 - $6.19 = $4.51 + 0.6% (12.2) = $4.54
53	@majes	Steem/US Dollar Price Charts for Nov 16th 2016 114 \| $4.49 - $0.14 = $4.36 + 1.7% (8.4) = $4.43
54	@abdullar	She is so cute even from the back.... ^^ 45 \| $4.51 - $0.12 = $4.39 + 0.8% (10.9) = $4.42
55	@leesunmoo	스팀잇 채굴보상율(인플레율) 변경이 혁명적이내요. 42 \| $4.67 - $0.34 = $4.33 + 2.0% (7.8) = $4.42
56	@johnallen	Puer Tea 普洱茶 203 \| $16.31 - $12.27 = $4.04 + 9.0% (3.7) = $4.40
57	@foxxycat	Post-STEEM FEST Depression 159 \| $14.66 - $10.31 = $4.35 + 0.3% (13.5) = $4.36
58	@narrowminded	7 REASONS I NO LONGER BELIEVE IN A PRETRIBULATIONAL RAPTURE - Reason 7 - A Video Series 169 \| $6.24 - $2.17 = $4.06 + 2.4% (7.3) = $4.16
59	@lyubovbar	Neat and Small Leaves in the Sunlight (Photos @lyubovbar) 55 \| $4.07 - $0.29 = $3.78 + 9.7% (3.5) = $4.15
60	@norbu	The Trafficker - An Original Poem 61 \| $3.94 - $0.20 = $3.74 + 9.7% (3.5) = $4.10
61	@levycore	My Latte Art - Animation Character 43 \| $4.09 - $0.04 = $4.05 + 1.2% (9.5) = $4.09
62	@unhorsepower777	Flower and Insects in the Dark - #23 57 \| $4.15 - $0.15 = $3.99 + 0.6% (11.9) = $4.02
63	@reddust	Project With Sean and Red Dust -- Pokemon Series -- 5 -- First Layer -- 198 \| $16.13 - $12.19 = $3.94 + 0.5% (12.5) = $3.96
64	@rmach	Useless information #1 – Peculiar lizard 109 \| $6.41 - $2.88 = $3.52 + 12.3% (3.1) = $3.96
65	@vannour	Macro Lens Smartphone [part 3] Small Snails 132 \| $8.56 - $4.71 = $3.85 + 2.6% (7.0) = $3.95
66	@leesunmoo	스팀 가치 상승의 열쇠는 결제 기능이 아닐가 싶다. 37 \| $4.08 - $0.25 = $3.82 + 0.9% (10.3) = $3.86
67	@dwinblood	Why bother? I'm sure you've heard that, and maybe said it. My answer: Johnny Appleseed 63 \| $4.14 - $0.30 = $3.84 + 0.0% (14.9) = $3.84
68	@timbot606	The Struggle - An Original Poem 114 \| $4.79 - $1.06 = $3.73 + 2.5% (7.2) = $3.82
69	@majes	Steem/Silver - Troy Ounce Price Charts for Nov 17th 2016 76 \| $3.57 - $0.02 = $3.55 + 4.0% (5.9) = $3.69
70	@robotev	Status Update for Day 77 of My Life as a Bot on Steemit 40 \| $3.71 - $0.12 = $3.59 + 0.2% (14.1) = $3.60
71	@gamgam	Massive Fraud 8,000 Tons of Paper Gold Dumped on Market 67 \| $3.60 - $0.01 = $3.59 + 0.1% (14.3) = $3.60
72	@morning	한제인은 쓰지 마세요 32 \| $3.47 - $0.05 = $3.42 + 4.8% (5.4) = $3.59
73	@knircky	$200 Bounty: Meniscus Torn. What to do? 111 \| $5.90 - $2.39 = $3.50 + 0.1% (14.4) = $3.51
74	@churdtzu	Trump presidency got you down? Don't go to Canada - come to Mexico! 150 \| $6.27 - $2.79 = $3.48 + 0.1% (14.5) = $3.48
75	@xiaohui	[Daily Update] Active Steemit users stats and trends analysis - Nov 17 \| [每日更新] Steemit 活动用户统计与趋势分析 11-17 69 \| $4.71 - $1.43 = $3.28 + 4.3% (5.6) = $3.42
76	@allmonitors	A Colorful Forest of Pines (Philippines) 24 \| $3.36 - $0.01 = $3.35 + 2.3% (7.4) = $3.42
77	@giantbear	Stop whining and don't give up! 71 \| $3.31 - $0.09 = $3.23 + 5.8% (4.9) = $3.41
78	@jejujinfarm	오늘 수능 보느라고 고생한 수험생들, 그리고 뒷바라지 하느라고 고생하신 부모님들~고생 많으셨습니다 70 \| $3.31 - $0.07 = $3.24 + 3.7% (6.1) = $3.36
79	@kevinwong	Steem Connects People: A Reflection / Dissection of Whatever Happened During Steemfest 387 \| $40.41 - $37.20 = $3.21 + 0.1% (14.3) = $3.21
80	@marcstevens	First Live Broadcast of Marc Stevens' No State Project 28 \| $3.88 - $0.68 = $3.20 + 0.2% (14.2) = $3.21

The Daily Tribune: Most Undervalued Posts of Nov 17 - Part I

Rankings

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

59

60

61

62

63

64

65

66

67

68

69

70

71

72

73

74

75

76

77

78